Assume that you are the assistant to the cfo of xyz company. your
The component costs should ideally be estimated on a after-tax basis as this provides more accurate representation actual cost needed in order finance activities. This due fact that taxes can significantly reduce amount available for investments thus making before-tax estimates less reliable when trying accurately determine how much money would need be invested given certain situation.
Moreover, by using after-tax numbers we also ensure that any tax related benefits (such as deductions or credits) are accounted for too which further helps provide more accurate results overall. Ultimately then, while both approaches have their place within financial analysis, utilizing post tax figures yields better results when attempting estimate XYZ’s WACC – thereby allowing company make more informed decisions moving forward.